There
has been a considerable amount of controversy in recent years concerning
the Georgia Flag. Many questions have been asked by citizens and many
people have tried to answer these questions from varying viewpoints.
In an attempt to answer the many questions, the GEORGIA FLAG FACTS
COMMITTEE has researched the development of the official GEORGIA
FLAG from its first mention in the official records of the state
government to present. The findings are presented here so the citizens
of Georgia might form their opinions concerning the GEORGIA FLAG
based upon FACTS.
Question: When did the State of Georgia first adopt an official flag?
Following the American Revolution, it was decided that all of the sovereign
states should adopt a flag design. Although no official action has ever
been found in the record, a common design was seen shortly thereafter
and was used fequently until 1879. It was a blue field with a white
Georgia State Seal in the center. (Authority: Hon. Ben Fortson, Secretary
of State of Georgia, June 1973.)
Question: If no record is found that the first commonly used flag was
officially adopted, when was the first official flag adopted?
During
the 1879 session of the Georgia General Assembly "... an Act to declare
and establish the flag fo the State of Georgia ..." was introduced by
a prominent Senator from Waynesboro named Col. Heman H. Perry. Col.
Perry was a well known lawyer and former colonel in the Confederate
States Army. His design was anadaptation of the first national flag
of the Confederate States of America, commonly know as "The Stars and
Bars". It was shown as a vertical blue bar on the flag staff third of
the flag with the remainder covered by three horizontal bars of equal
width. The middle bar was white with the upper and lower bars red. In
1905, the State Coat of Arms, or seal, was added in the middle of the
blue bar.
Col. Perry's purpose was clearly to remember the Confederate States
of America, the fallen nation of which Georgia had been a part. Other
former Confederate states also adopted variations of the "Stars and
Bars". (Authority: Georgia Official and Statistical Register, 1954-1955
published by the Georgia Secretary of State and Miss Carol Hart, Director
of Archives.)
Question: The state flag is no longer shown with the Confederate "Stars
and Bars" adaptation. When was it changed?
During
the 1956 session of the Georgia General Assembly. (Authority: Acts of
the Georgia General Assembly, 1956 session.)
Question: What is the 1956 design and where did it originate?
The
1956 design is an adaptation of the Cross of Saint Andrew. The version
used in the official flag of Georgia was taken directly from the field
or battle flag of the Provisional Army of the Confederate States of
America. The design was used by the Army of the Confederate States of
America - of which Georgia was a part - during the War Between the States.
The Stars and Bars
St. Andrew's Cross
Question:
Why did the Confederate States Army not use the "Stars and Bars" alone;
after all, it was their official flag?
The
Stars and Bars proved to be much too similar in design to the Stars
and Stripes of the United States. Since the two nations were at war
in 1861 when the design was created, needless casualties on both sides
were encountered at the first Battle of Manassas due to the confusion
caused by the similarity. A new design was ordered by the Confederate
generals. The Cross of Saint Andrew, the ancient symbol of Scotland,
was used by a Virginia regiment during the battle. A general suggested
that it was sufficiently unique to serve the purpose. It was then adapted
in square fashion so as to allow it to flow easily in the breeze. The
flag was the carried by the combat troops of the Confederate nation
for the remainder of its existence. (Authority: 'The Flags of the Confederacy'
by Devereaux
Cannon.)
Question: Who proposed that the Georgia flag be changed to reflect the
Cross of Saint Andrew rather than the Stars and Bars?
Senator
Willis Neal Hardin and Senator Jefferson Lee Davis introduced the bill
that was drafted by the same man who designed and created the Present
State Flag, State Democratic Party Chairman and Civil War buff John
Sammons Bell. The new design was created because the old Confederate
design had become "meaningless" in the words of Bell. He wanted to forever
perpetuate the memory of the Confederate soldier who fought and died
for his state. (Authority: Interview with John Sammons Bell by Vivian
Price published in the 'DeKalb News/Sun,' page2-F 13 July 1988.)
Question:
Why was the flag changed?
Judge
John Sammons Bell, former Chief Judge of the Georgia Court of Appeals
and designer of the current flag stated that the purpose of the change
was "to honor our ancestors who fought and died and who have been so
much maligned." (Authority: Interview with John Sammons Bell by Vivian
Price published in the 'DeKalb News/Sun,' page2-F 13 July 1988.)
Question:
Some have claimed that the 1954 school desegregation decision by the
U.S. Supreme Court stimulated the change in 1956. Is this true?
Concerning
those who claim that the flag was "... designed as a last desperate
gasp of defiance against integration," Judge Bell said "Absolutely nothing
could be further from the truth ... every bit of it is untrue." He further
stated that "Anybody who says anything to the contrary is wrong or perpetuating
a willful lie." (Authority: Interview with John Sammons Bell by Vivian
Price published in the 'DeKalb News/Sun,' page2-F 13 July 1988.)
Question: Some claim that Hardin, Davis and Bell might not be willing
to tell the truth - that they might have tried to hide their 'real'
purpose. Could this be true?
These
gentlemen denied any such impropriety. In the year 1956 several newspaper
accounts of the proposed change in the GEORGIA FLAG were published.
In none of the articles was there any hint that the flag change was
for any reason other than that stated by the gentlemen who proposes
the change. (Authority: The Atlanta Journal, 2 Feb. 1956, page 6; The
Atlanta Constitution, 2 Feb. 1956, page 8; The Atlanta Journal/Constitution,
5 Feb. 1956, page C-1; The Atlanta Constitution, 10 Feb. 1956, front
page; The Atlanta Journal 10 Feb. 1956, page A-4.)
Question: Judge Bell is still alive yet Senator Hardin and Senator Davis
are now deceased. Is there any evidence that they felt the same?
In
letters to the Flag Facts Committee, the sons of both senators unequivocally
stated that their fathers never mentioned any purpose for the redesign
of the Georgia Flag other than as a means of honoring their ancestors
who fought for Southern independence. They specifically stated that
their fathers were disturbed that anyone would claim that they were
using the flag change as a political issue. (Authority: Letters to the
committee dated 17 Sept. 1990 from Willis Hardin, Jr. and letter to
the committee dated 1 Feb. 1990 from Jefferson L. Davis, Jr.)
Question:
Isn't it true that these gentlemen would not have admitted to any motivation
concerning defiance of integration in 1956?
Any
reading of the newspapers in 1956 shows that politicians who believed
in defiance of integration were not at all reluctant to say so in the
news interviews. In fact some thought that political advantage could
be gained by such positions. (Authority: The Atlanta Journal and The
Atlanta Constitution during the periof 1954 to 1956.)
Question:
Is it just a coincidence that the flag was changed two years after the
Brown vs. Board of Education case in the U.S. Supreme Court?
It
must be remembered that Confederate patriotism was running high in 1956.
On January 20 1956 it was announced that the Civil War Centennial Committee
would be formed to plan commemorative events for the 100th anniversary
of the War between the States. This coincided with the deaths of the
last remaining Confederate veterans. The last soldier in Georgia died
in 1952. The last soldier of the entire Confederacy died in 1959. In
the years between, the old veterans were one by one passing away. A
great deal of sympathy was felt throughout the South for the old soldiers
and many commemorative activities took place. (Authority: The Atlanta
Journal, 20 Jan. 1956, page A-5; 'The South's Last Boys in Gray' by
Professor Jay S. Hoar, University of Maine.)
Question:
Since 1956, has the issue of the flag come before the General Assembly?
Until
the mid 1980s, the issue was brought up twice by a lady representing
a portion of Sumter County. In 1970 a motion to postpone the resolution
was overwhelmingly passed. When it the issue came to the floor of the
House of Representatives in 1972 it was defeated 139 to 20. Clearly,
the General Assembly did not want to change the flag.
Question: Isn't it true that a large part of the population wants the
flag to be changed?
Few
polls have been done concerning public opinion about the flag. However,
in February 1988 the Gwinnett Daily
news, a newspaper covering the Metropolitan Atlanta area, published
a poll which indicated that 92% of those polled wanted the state flag
to stay the same. (Authority: The Gwinnett Daily News, 7 Feb. 1988,
front page.)
It is hoped that this information will help the citizens of Georgia
become more familiar with their flag and how it was developed, researched
& authored by Charles Kelly Barrow.
Signing of the bill to change the flag in 1956.