Arguments Against Confederate
Symbols - And Why They Fail
Argument:
"Since Confederate symbols were erected and raised in defiance
of court ordered integration during the 1950's and 60', they should
be removed."
This
argument goes hand-in-hand with those who try to portray the 1950's,
especially in the South, as a decade of hate. This approach was popular
with "civil rights" groups in Georgia as well as the liberal
media. The Georgia state flag, for example, was changed in 1956. Those
who want the flag changed today, claim that the current state flag was
established as a slap in the face of court ordered integration, even
though records indicate otherwise.
Integration
was ordered by the courts in 1952. If Georgia legislators were angry
over integration, it would not have taken them four years to change
the Georgia flag. If defiance had been the reason for the flag's change,
it would have been changed the very same day as the court decision!
After all, opposing integration in the 1950's was a popular position
to hold, and it earned votes for politicians, both in the north and
the South.
The formula
for providing quality education has always been an illusive one with
many variables. In the 1950's, some of those variables discussed by
the members of the state legislatures in the north and the South included
teacher salaries, improved curriculum, funding for new schools and integration.
Any state whose elected officials did not thoroughly debate how court
ordered integration might effect quality education was done a serious
disservice.
Yes, debates over segregation and integration took place during the
1950's, but the timing of those debates was chosen by the civil rights
movement and not by the defenders of segregation who would have preferred
that the debates never occur at all. Had the courts ordered integration
50 years earlier or 50 years later, the 1950's would have still been
a decade of heritage not hate.
In the 1950's
and especially the South, a nationwide preparation for the "Civil
War Centennial" had begun. This event would include many states
with activities spanning several years. The 1996 Olympics in Atlanta
paled in comparison to the celebration surrounding the historic centennial
event.
President Dwight D. Eisenhower issued a special proclamation calling
on all state and federal employees to take part in the festivities.
The Postal Service issued a special set of stamps to commemorate the
event. Knowing that many visitors coming to the South would take guided
tours, hundreds and thousands of historic markers were also placed throughout
the 1950's in many states.
The decade of the 1950's saw an enormous outpouring of Southern awareness
that had its beginnings in the late 1930's with the incredible success
of Margaret Mitchell's novel, "Gone With The Wind" and its
subsequent movie premier in Atlanta. Hailed as an overwhelming success,
this classic and moving story of the South's struggle for independence
and then survival, continues to serve as an inspiration to millions
of Americans today.